
Home Events Activities Links To Join Archives
"WHAT
CAN WE LEARN FROM ZIMBABWE?
People Planning and Working for a Positive Future"
BZS
DAYSCHOOL 2002
Saturday 14 September 2002, 11am-4.30pm
Conway Hall, 25 Red Lion Square, London WC1
WORKSHOP REPORTS
Around 150 people took part in the BZS 2202 Dayschool, most of whom took part in in the morning and afternoon workshops of their choice. Those workshop reports that have been received follow below: unfortunately we do not
as yet have reports from all of them.
Margaret Ling, Dayschool Coordinator
| REPORT OF THE OPENING PLENARY PANEL
Prepared by Marieke Clarke Grassroots Performing Arts under Ephson Ngadya opened the day with music. Ephson shared his experience of working with GPA- the need to express ourselves through the theatre and arts, in order to develop our self-worth and sense of responsibility as young people. Formal organisation is necessary to handle issues of health, economics, poverty and oppression. We need to encourage as much participation as possible. How do small theatre companies survive in such harsh times as these? We need to have a place in which to express ourselves. Bigger groups may make false claims of being representative because they do not have our bottom-up approach. We lobby and advocate to benefit the work of young people. The societies-such as churches, community centres- which we serve at home can measure our success. So we are glad here to have the chance to talk about our approach. Diana Jeater: Our dayschool has always tried to practise the same approach of people to people linking. Thoko Matshe began by speaking in isiNdebele for quite some time; unfortunately your rapporteuse is insufficiently able to understand the language to be able to report. Later she said: We are a different people from the people you know us as when we live in a country where there are so many sensitivities eg. To sounds of approaching danger (from the police) . We have qualifications and skills which we cannot practise in our own country. How long and what will it take? Wellington Chibebe Secretary-General of the ZCTU: From a protracted liberation struggle, we welcomed our heroes. We are now preparing to run away, to listen to the noises, to find new ways of making a living. He told how people leave Matabeleland South to go to South Africa. Outsiders say "Why do you let one man ruin your country? Today people are talking about white farmers and farm workers and their children. These people are by origin Malawians, Mozambiquans, Zambians. What are we inculcating in them? As Trade Unionists what are we to think as farm workers are retrenched and you may have to go to a Border Gezi camp before you go to university? Mugabe was our hero even in 1995. Can we say the same today? It was announced that the collections would be for displaced people in Zimbabwe and go to various organisations.
Report by Diana Jeater Sustainability panels at BZS Dayschool, 2002. The morning panel began with Ennie Chipembere talking about the work preparing for the World Summit. She outlined the involvement of NGOs in seeking to develop a coherent position based on Zimbabwe's various interests in sustainability. In particular, Ennie outlined her own involvement in the 'Brainstorming and Priority Setting on World Summit for Sustainable Development' forum held in Harare in August, which brought together a wide range of interest groups to thrash out issues such as the relative roles of government, NGOs and the private sector in promoting sustainable development. Ennie provided us with several reports relating
to the preparation for the WSSD, that are now held by Diana Jeater for
anyone interested to consult. They are: Ennie raised a number of issues regarding the preparations
for the WSSD, including: Ennie's presentation set the framework for the next two contributions. Sam Page described, using slides, her project to
develop organic cotton cultivation in northern Zimbabwe. She made many
pertinent observations, including: Nick James described the uses and value of indigenous
food sources in cotton-growing economies, emphasising their vital role
in keeping people alive and healthy during drought seasons. This led to
a lively debate in which several issues were raised: Finally, it was noted the DfID's approach to 'development'
has been to attempt to impose capital-intensive, non-sustainable farming
methods. Jyoti Fernandes suggested that farmers in Zimbabwe should link
with campaigners in India who are attempting to regain control over their
development process and to reject aid packages that require big marketing
and productivity increases as the marker of success. * * * The afternoon panel was much smaller, and addressed
some difficult questions about how we should think about 'development'
and 'sustainability'. · We started by returning to the suggestion from the morning's panel about linking with Indian farmers, and the question 'will Zimbabwean farmers be more likely to be ready to learn from Indian farmers than from UK advisors on sustainable farming?' · This led to a discussion about whether Zimbabwean farmers actually need to learn anything from farmers elsewhere, and, even if they do, is it our job in the UK to be trying to organise this for them? There was some disquiet about the constant assumption that 'we' can 'help' Zimbabwe's farmers by suggesting that they are doing something wrong and ought to learn from someone else. · It was observed that Zimbabwean farmers grow cash crops at the highest yields they can manage because they want to be part of the global consumer society. Their needs and interests are very different from those of the sort of people who offer advice on sustainability in rich countries, who have consciously rejected consumerism and high yields as the main aim of their farming. · Instead, we asked 'what might we learn from Zimbabwe, and who might we be willing to learn it from?' This led on to a discussion about drought management, and the work of Mr Phiri. It was noted that Mr Phiri's work is not recognised as special and different by his neighbours, many of whom still regard water management as a question of mechanical expertise rather than requiring a different way of thinking about stewardship of the land. It was noted that many of these farmers do posses remarkable mechanical expertise that has enabled them to access water, and that they have a pride in these achievements. Our obsession with Mr Phiri's work may seem to be a rejection of their expertise. Our championing of sustainability may also appear as a new version of a typical colonial pattern, deciding that Africans do not know how to farm properly, and that we know better what is good for them. · The question of water management led on to a discussion about the viability of much of the newly-redistributed land, previously used for ranching by white farmers, and growing mostly mpane scrub. In particular, we discussed tree cultivation and the need for annual cycles of fruiting trees, so that there is always one set of trees producing a good crop. The need to make the new plots viable year-on-year straight away may cause difficulties and cash-flow problems for the new farmers on these lands, which will encourage the use of chemical inputs and probably also GMO crops. It was noted that Agritex in Zimbabwe also has little interest in or knowledge of organic methods. · This brought us back to the question of whether farmers in Zimbabwe therefore needed outside help and advice, and, if so, what kind of role we could play from the UK. It was noted that there are very good sustainable farming organisations offering training and support within Zimbabwe itself, but that they have limited impact (as the Soil Association etc. have limited but valuable impact here). It might be seen as arrogant to assume that outsiders can do more to 'help' than these internal agencies. · Overall, the workshop highlighted the often-overlooked political difficulties in attempting to foster and maintain sustainable land-use projects, when the interests of those involved in low-input farming across the globe are so different, and reflecting different concerns and available choices. However, the genuine warmth and mutual learning of grassroots contacts, such as those between Jyoti's community in Somerset and Mr Phiri and Clever Tabaziba in Zimbabwe, was seen as a positive way forward. · We agreed to pursue the India option, because it is about pressuring DfID, which does seem an appropriate focus for a UK-based organisation. Also, via Jyoti, it would encourage a three-way linking between small-scale sustainable farmers in UK, India and Zimbabwe.
HIV/AIDS and Food Security Report by Bridget Samuels Rosemary Zvirawa, from ZHIVAF (Zimbabwe HIV and AIDS Forum) talked about her experience working with Zimbabweans in London through the NHS and through ZHIVAF since the early nineties. ZHIVAF's main work at the moment is advising people how to access health institutions, counselling and some hospital/home visits. At times people are not aware of their rights. Treatment is free and under the Human Rights Act, people who have been diagnosed HIV+ cannot be sent home as there is no treatment if they are sent back. However, there are a great many other problems faced by Zimabweans in the UK. People enter the U.K. roughly under these groups: 1.Visitors (6 month permits) 2.Students 3.Nurses/professionals 4. Asylum seekers 5. Other Many are working long hours for low rates. They cannot rest properly, often are not eating well, fighting with the Home Office, struggling with many adjustments eg. childcare. (There is no extended family to care for children, childcare is v. expensive, legal issues of child protection have to be understood.) Many high profile professionals find themselves in menial jobs, and this often leads to family breakdowns with men frustrated, their egos crushed. The stress resulting from these problems makes recovery extremely difficult. Most Zimbabweans, positive or not want, to be buried at home. The cost of returning the body is between £1,800 and £6000. There are a lot of discussions on this issue within the community on forming a burial society or insurance to fund transportation while one is alive. There is a large group of people won't go home when they are very sick - there is the fear of being regarded as a failure, and also the psychological burden of not wanting to admit you are dying. Rosemary mentioned 3 London organisations who are dealing with HIV/AIDS among African communities: Terence Higgins Trust, The Lighthouse, and Black Liners in Brixton. There are also other Zimbabwean groups e.g. churches who are visit the ill, dying and bereaved (e.g. Zimbabwe Fellowship) The few active members in Zhivaf would like to see other Zimbabweans - positive or not - take over the running and the recruitment of younger volunteers into ZHIVAF,especially for Health Promotions purposes. Membership has dwindled while the need is increasing. CONTACT HER THROUGH BZS!! Dr Theresa Watts spoke more about the history of AIDS in Africa, with numerous case studies from her own experience in Zambia, Zimbabwe and S.Africa. She mentioned some of the causes of the rapid spread of the disease in southern Africa via trade routes ,prostitution, migrant labour and the high cost of lobola (men cannot afford to marry, and have informal relations instead.) She showed a 'key diagram' which indicated clearly the complex costs which fall on a household in which there is an AIDS patient. AIDS causes a significant loss of labour for producing food in subsistence farms. Cash crops are diverted to food crops, causing an additional loss of income. There is a need to consider simple affordable mechanisation (eg animal ploughing and weeding). Her work on the relation between TB and AIDS has shown that many people who become ill get TB and may give it to cattle (and vice versa), and that people are now beginning to think that if they've got TB they've got AIDS. Dr Sam Page made the point that 'You can't live with AIDS. You die of AIDS, but you can live with HIV.' She went on to talk about the critical importance of caring for the health of those who are HIV positive. In the UK, such people often live for 15 years or more, due to a healthier diet, and the use of supplements, vitamins etc. In Zimbabwe they will be lucky to live 5 years. The implications of this are enormous. IF HIV+ MOTHERS COULD STAY ALIVE FOR 15 YEARS THE NUMBER OF AIDS ORPHANS WOULD BE DRASTICALLY REDUCED. Peasant farmers in Zimbabwe are starting to grow traditional foods again in reaction to the concentration on hybrid maize. These crops (e.g. cassava, sweet potatoes) need less inputs and less labour and are high in nutritional value. Old people's indigenous knowledge becomes highly significant. The DFDD is spending millions on researching spermicides.This money could surely be better spent distributing zinc/selenium and vitamins A, B, C - possibly through the church. Girls are not only 5 x more infected than boys,
but they are often supporting their orphaned siblings as well. Rosemary
added that here too, it is girls/women who are looking after those who
are ill. WORKSHOP 4 (morning & afternoon session): CULTURE & THE ARTS Morning session: Going to Scale - The Performing
Arts in Zimbabwe
Report by Marieke Clarke Pat Brickhill produced a beautifully written and thought-out paper. (See Written Presentations.) Questions: Ranjana Ash: What is so terrible in Zimbabwe? Pat Brickhill: Drew Shaw: Probably critical distance can't be established in such difficult circumstances. Pat Brickhill: But Bill Saidi (of the Daily News) did write very well in similar circumstances. There is no sense of a mass movement anti-government. MDC have provided a good opportunity to dispel the prevailing isolation but have been very naïve. Events like today's do help. Drew Shaw: One could also record personal experiences.
Morning session: Media, Freedom of Information and Governance - The Role of Public Access Report by Forward Maisokwadzo Georgina Godwin, SW Radio Africa -She talked about the role of broadcasting and
how the Zimbabweans have benefited from SW Radio Radio Africa's news bulletins. The Floor - A participant raised the notion that the media
and mostly the British media tend to focus more on white commercial farmers
"although they are not facing threat unlike their black counterpart
from the opposition who are constantly under severe harassment and torture
but unfortunately their difficulties or dangers they are experiencing
is not reported in the media here in the UK." MY OBSERVATION FROM THE SEMINAR Independent broadcasting could be the most effective way in reaching the rural areas if resources and the law permit to set up such a station in Zimbabwe. However, this should be complemented by a vibrant newspaper industry. Afternoon session: The Breakdown of the Rule of
Law in Zimbabwe
Morning session: Internal displacement and the Brain Drain - consequences within Zimbabwe Report by Katrina Phillips Speakers: Wellington Chibebe, Thoko Matshe, Stephen
Damuputarai Stephen Damuputarai: Thoko Matshe: Displacement is closely linked to violence in Zimbabwe, such as the camps of violence. In my village 90% of people are my relatives, so intimidation works well. But family members are being turned against each other. Displacement also stops the protection of knowing those around you. Lots of young people have been taken, have fled here, and have lost their youth. As they are in the UK, their parents in Zimbabwe believe they should provide, when they should be learning and having fun. Displacement destroys the fabric of the people and rebuilding takes so much longer. Skills are lost, education missed and some people never go back to the level they once reached. Starting afresh takes you back many years. Displacement to another country leads to a false reality of what home is really like. So people don't go home. Wellington Chibebe: 123% inflation, the situation is on the edge. The Congo war. Poverty at 70%. Unemployment 80% of the population. Can you wonder why people are leaving? This is why doctors leave - they get a pittance. They have to respect their profession and they feel betrayed to be in a hospital with no drugs. Politics - the issue of the land. All agree the need for land redistribution. But has to be equitable, legal and transparent. Not to use the race card as a smokescreen. The farmworkers are no longer human beings in Zimbabwe. Land is not elastic - 12 million hectares of land and 14 million people - so we are already short. If you stretch elastic it becomes plastic. Stretch plastic and it snaps. There will be another revolution. Today we are displacing people for the political. And those who stay are watched, here and there. Well watch. Things will change. Soon. Questions: Q: How to help? WC: With political and moral support. Unlock SA and Mozambique, make sure they put pressure on Zimbabwe. TM: It's not about land or white farmers. I DO NOT WANT LAND. It's about governance. One thing that has to change is the UK media portrayal. Influence must be bought to bear on SADC. They have sold the people of Zimbabwe. It's not about Mugabe but a system the props him up.
Report by Katrina Phillips Speakers: Dadirai Chikwenga, Adrian Lunga, Ephraim
Tapa, Matthew Sanyanga Dadirai Chikewnga: Adrian Lunga: Mathew Sanyanga: Ephraim Tapa: Charles Maphosa: Questions: Q: People should know that you can study and use computers for free at Learning Direct centres. Q: We are forced to break the law - have to work whether allowed to or not. Q: We need a network or association. (General discussion, book handed around for contacts to be written down, and proposal that ZA should continue to keep people in touch with events and try to organise further gatherings.) Q: Need to push Home Office and Zimbabwe High Commission. Q: Zimbabweans need to share info - if they have a good idea they tend to keep it to themselves. We do not help each other. Q: Low paid illegal jobs. Are you exploited? Yes. £2.50 per hour etc. AL: Need to be united for something, not against. ET: Zimbabweans don't see eye to eye. This is a result of our selfishness and we need to lose it. BC: How do we reach people who won't approach because of their status? ET: Zimfest had 2500 whites, 100 blacks. I went to a concert and it was packed with blacks, three whites. Who are we? Who are all the Zimbabweans? 7 (morning & afternoon sessions): MUSIC &
PERFORMING ARTS WORKSHOP 8 (morning & afternoon sessions): CHILDREN'S
ACTIVITY PROGRAMME |